The New York Times characterized his work as a “single viral video,” while NPR featured commentary from a University of Minnesota media law professor who suggested Shirley was promoting a particular narrative
As the video gained attention, several major news organizations, including CNN, PBS, and The New York Times, dismissed Shirley’s findings as a viral video rather than an investigative report. Journalist Stella Escobedo commented on X that response was “an indictment” on corporate mainstream media, which led Shirley to respond: “Just wait until I post part 2, they are going to go insane.”